Grading is a deeply ingrained feature of modern education, being both an administrative staple and a key metric for student achievement. However, while assessment is grounded in clear, educational goals, in practice the application of grading systems can be quite varied, raising questions about the impact on teacher workloads, equity and motivation for students, as well as the very purpose of grading.
Administrative burden and teacher stress
For teachers, one significant drawback of grading is simply the amount of time and energy it demands. Teachers may understand the benefits of grading yet still bemoan having to grade, often because they are continuously juggling multiple tasks and thus naturally experience grading as a stress factor in their work. Additionally, the amount of time that goes towards grading can, in the long-term, stifle course development as well as the teacher’s own professional development, despite the teacher’s desire to pedagogically improve or be more innovative in their teaching (Schinske & Tanner 2014).
Grading inconsistency and the issue of fairness
From a student perspective, issues with grading often center around equity and equality, particularly regarding a perceived lack of consistency in how teachers grade. While teams of teachers or even organizations may attempt to minimize such risks with regular benchmarking or by implementing broad grading policies, differences in grading practices appear to be inevitable. Studies show that not only can two teachers give drastically different grades for the same piece of work, but that a single teacher, when having viewed the same submission twice but two weeks apart, might give two different grades (Schinske & Tanner 2014; Bloxham et al. 2011).