Pedagogical development

Practical Challenges of Grading

Grading is a deeply ingrained feature of modern education, being both an administrative staple and a key metric for student achievement. However, while assessment is grounded in clear, educational goals, in practice the application of grading systems can be quite varied, raising questions about the impact on teacher workloads, equity and motivation for students, as well as the very purpose of grading.

Administrative burden and teacher stress

For teachers, one significant drawback of grading is simply the amount of time and energy it demands. Teachers may understand the benefits of grading yet still bemoan having to grade, often because they are continuously juggling multiple tasks and thus naturally experience grading as a stress factor in their work. Additionally, the amount of time that goes towards grading can, in the long-term, stifle course development as well as the teacher’s own professional development, despite the teacher’s desire to pedagogically improve or be more innovative in their teaching (Schinske & Tanner 2014).

Grading inconsistency and the issue of fairness

From a student perspective, issues with grading often center around equity and equality, particularly regarding a perceived lack of consistency in how teachers grade. While teams of teachers or even organizations may attempt to minimize such risks with regular benchmarking or by implementing broad grading policies, differences in grading practices appear to be inevitable. Studies show that not only can two teachers give drastically different grades for the same piece of work, but that a single teacher, when having viewed the same submission twice but two weeks apart, might give two different grades (Schinske & Tanner 2014; Bloxham et al. 2011). 

Image 1. Differences in teachers’ grading practices raise questions about equity and equality for students. (Kristensen 2017)

Additionally, teachers may primarily mark holistically or use comparisons with other students’ submissions to determine a grade, only turning to task criteria as a secondary guide to either refine or justify the grade. Such grading practices can become problematic as they undermine the trust between teachers and students, as well as the students’ ability to trust given criteria (Bloxham et al. 2011). The problem can also extend to national curriculum and standards, which, despite their best intentions, are not immune to regional or local interpretations (Ecclestone 2001; Knight & Yorke 2003; Price & Rust 1999, cited in Bloxham et al. 2011).

Systemic challenges and learner motivation

A variety of other concerns come into play when looking at grading from a wider perspective. Schneider and Hutt (2013, cited in Schinske & Tanner 2014) state that grading has moved away from traditional, pedagogical purposes and instead towards more of an organizational tool that facilitates communication and coordination between educational institutions. There are common examples of this we can see here at LAB, such as decisions on RPL applications or language proficiency, as well as the movement of students between different universities. Additionally, some suggest that grading does not actually represent what a student has learnt or can do but instead acts as a reflection of their ability to ‘play the game’, meaning the game of school or education (Towns & Robinson 1993; Scouller 1998; Stanger-Hall 2012, cited in Schinske & Tanner 2014).

This is further compounded by arguments that grading reduces students’ extrinsic motivation for learning, and also plays on their potential fears of shame, punishment or failure, including a desire to outcompete others (Harter 1978; Butler & Nisan 1986; Butler 1988; Crooks 1988; Pulfrey et al. 2011, cited in Schinske & Tanner 2014). Feedback and grading are also traditionally given by the teacher, which Schinske and Tanner (2014) believe has deprived students of the ability and opportunity to learn how to regulate their own learning and critically evaluate their own work.

Conclusion

Examining these challenges isn't a suggestion to remove grades from education or an attempt to undermine the real, useful information that they can give on student learning. Rather, it is about questioning how grading operates in practice and the trade-offs that can occur as a result. By recognizing the gap between how assessment is intended to work and how it actually works, we gain a clearer picture of some of the everyday realities of evaluation and can thus help to identify areas in our own teaching here at LAB that could benefit from further reflection, research and improvement.

AI has been used to improve the clarity of some phrases. 

References

Bloxham, S., Boyd, P. & Orr, S. 2011. Mark my words: the role of assessment criteria in UK higher education grading practices. Studies in Higher Education. Vol 36 (6), 655─670. Cited 1 Oct 2026. Available at https://doi.org/10.1080/03075071003777716

Kristensen, M. 2017. High angle photography of group of people sitting at chairs. Unsplash. Cited 4 Nov 2026. Available at https://unsplash.com/photos/high-angle-photography-of-group-of-people-sitting-at-chairs-3aVlWP-7bg8

Schinske, J. & Tanner, K. 2014. Teaching more by grading less (or differently). CBE – Life Sciences Education. Vol 13 (2), 159─166. Cited 1 Oct 2026. Available at https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.cbe-14-03-0054

 

See also